Forum home Problem solving

Gaillardia death

Every year I plant a yellow/red border with coreopsis, gaillardia and other perrenials in the same colour range. Every year the gaillardias die and have to be replaced while everything else seems to survive reasonably well. Does anyone else have the same problem and what am I doing wrong. Is there a solution to my woes?image


  • granmagranma Posts: 1,929

    I love gaillardia , but grow it each year from seed - mine doesnt survive so I understood it to be an annual . This year If I get the heating sorted in my greenhouse I shall try and over winter some . Are yours alright until the first frosts ? I lose some of mine then unless they are protected by other foilage such as phormium .

    It is the same with Rudbeckia's too .

  • I have always understood them to be perrenials... at least the ones I grow are, and they are sold in the perrenial section of the GC. I shall look them up and come back.

  • punkdocpunkdoc Posts: 14,966

    Although most of them are perennials it is not unusual for them not to survive our winters, so they are probably best treated as annuals.

    How can you lie there and think of England
    When you don't even know who's in the team

    S.Yorkshire/Derbyshire border
  • Red TulipRed Tulip Posts: 24

    I have the same problem with 'perennial' gallardia and some coreopsis and as for coneflowers (echinacea) a complete waste of time (and $$$). I have found coreopsis 'Zagreb" to be hardy (3rd year now) and roots well from cuttings. Coreopsis 'limerock ruby' which in my ignorance appeared to look similiar to "Zagreb" was a complete failure. I'm on the Wirral and have quite a frost pocket but I would be very interested to hear of any varieties that people have found to be hardier


  • If so many of us seem to have problems with Gaillardias, and they behave as if they are annuals, perhaps the powers that be  and growers should consider relabelling them as annuals? At the very least they should come with a health warning. Perhaps this year I will dig them up and overwinter them under cover. Echinaceas are another plant that either disappear or go downhill in year 2. This week I dug over my bed and found lots of coreopsis still viable. But not sure of variety. 

    Thanks everyone so far... your comments have explained lots.

  • LynLyn Posts: 23,190

    Maybe I can help you with gaillardias, i had the ones called kobald, after they flowered, they shot out little side plants, if you dig down you get a bit of root on, pot them up and keep in greenhouse over winter, i have just planted t

    hem out now. 

    Gardening on the wild, windy west side of Dartmoor. 

  • Red TulipRed Tulip Posts: 24

    Thank you Lyn, I will look out for 'Kobald" and give it a try.

  • -- Posts: 88

    It might be my less-than-reasonable garden, but the shoots my gaillardias produced

    have not been the healthiest, rather short-lived instead.

  • A few years ago, led in part by the RHS we were all encouraged to plant "prarie gardens/beds"... remember Piet Ouldorf? I was never very impressed by the basic untidy mess which many of these new borders appeared to be. The effort at Wisley was particularly unimpressive. It now appears that some of the recommended plants (see above) are not particularly suited to our conditions. I would guess that the basic problem is our winters rather than the summers. In the meantime we have all spent a shedload of money acieving very little. Shame? Beware untried new fads.image

  • chickychicky Posts: 10,403

    I love the prairie borders at Wisley !  Each to their own.image

    I have some Gallardias, bought last year, that have come through the winter.  They look healthy now, but remains to be seen whether they will flower.  I am in the SouthEast, but in a frost pocket.  My rudbeckias make it through most years too (not the one when we were down to -15!) - but echinaceas are a bit hit and miss.

    I do have problems with coreopsis being eaten to extinction - is that likely to be slugs ??

Sign In or Register to comment.