Forum home Wildlife gardening

Feeding blackbirds

Does anyone have any bright ideas about how I can make sure that those huge fat pigeons can't get at the fried bread and seed I put out for blackbirds and other small birds which don't use hanging feeders?



  • nutcutletnutcutlet PeterboroughPosts: 26,850

    Shoot them? 

  • sotongeoffsotongeoff Posts: 9,802

    You can't there is a pecking order-I find the pigeons have their go-the smaller birds wait till they have gone- and nip in thenimage

  • I have the same problem, I put mealworms and suet pellets out for the birds but the pigeons and starlings eat them all before the others can get a look in.  If they try to get in they just get chased away.  I can see them sitting in the trees watching and waiting.

  • Kathy 2Kathy 2 Posts: 122

    I have bird trays hanging in the trees at the front and back of my house. The pigeons can't get into them no matter how much they try! On the other hand, the blackbirds have no trouble getting onto them - although the young blackbirds take some time to work it out. At the moment, the robin is trying to see everything off to protect "his" food. image  I always do the bird watch, but the last couple of years not seen much at all on birdwatch weekend. image image

  • We had the same problem - woodpigeons and magpies. We bought a seed tray which had an adjustable canopy over it. You can set it to the height for the size of bird which you wish to feed. Magpie did try knocking it off the pole to get at the food, but I think it just ended up with a headache.

  • In our garden the pigeons and starlings feed the blackbirds! I fill up the tray on the feeding station, and hang fatballs. The pigeons, doves and starlings make a right mess - and the blackbirds clear it up!

  • I tend to put out dried fruit for the blackbirds, to make sure they get something.  The wood pigeons also like it but the other pigeons leave it alone.  Try to spare a thought for the pigeons, though - they can't help what they are and they're hungry too.  

  • PetaPeta Posts: 13

    Thank you all so much for your responses.  I know the pigeons need to eat too, Heliotrope, but they do seem to hoover up anything and everything.  Perhaps the most helpful suggestion comes from Flower Lady - I wonder where you got your food tray?  And I had to laugh at Nutcutlet's idea; I must admit that those fat breasts look mouthwatering!

  • image


     I feed mine with apples on skewers (as that stops the seaguls/foxes walking off witht them) the pidgeons and starlings aren't interested in them. At the mo i must be feeding about 6 Blackbirds.  I do put out some raisons and currents as well to boast them up a bit .

  • Jean GenieJean Genie Posts: 1,724

    Steve , what a brilliant idea ! I'm going to try that. Lovely photos.image

    Just been looking at your pics on the wildlife thread. Very jealous of your goldfinches, we only get a fleeting glimpe of them now and again. We did have a pair of nuthatches that used to visit but we've not seen them for a while either ,  We do have a gang of longtails though . image

Sign In or Register to comment.