Forum home Fruit & veg

James Grieve apple

We planted a James Grieve sappling in autum 2011 and have had a small crop of a dozen apples this year, but there doesn't seem to be any new growth on the tree at all, which has quite surprised us.

Question is, should it have grown at all, or is it because its the first year in the ground?

Another question is should we prune it this year to encourage growth next year?

We did actually lightly prune it in the winter, maybe we shouldn't have. Followed these instructions.



  • Alina WAlina W Posts: 1,445

    It'll be because it's concentrating on putting down roots.

    I personally don't prune mine unless it's getting too big, and it flowers and fruits well.

  • I have had a similar problem with a Greensleeves variety which seems barely to have stayed alive this year since planting about 12 months ago. I think it's a drainage issue in my case... clay soil, wet Spring, slow drainage. I dug its hole well on a slight slope and added plenty of compost and bonemeal. I'm now considering digging it up, redigging the hole extensively with broken bricks etc too.

  • Alina WAlina W Posts: 1,445

    I might leave that alone for another year to see what happens. If you do dig it up, check that your hole hasn't turned into a pond, with water draining into it and staying there.


  • WelshonionWelshonion Posts: 3,114

    Jim, try not to type in upper case!  All nurseries which stock apple trees will sell James Grieve, it is a very well-known variety.

  • sotongeoffsotongeoff Posts: 9,802

    And probably not the best idea to give out an e-mail address on a public forum for all to see??

  • Matty2Matty2 Posts: 4,817

    When I planted my fruit trees I read - RHS book- to take the blossom off the first year so that they concentrate on root growth and structure. It was sad pulling off the open blossoms. Last year, their 2nd year, I had blossom and a small crop of apples, no pears though, and they seem to be really well rooted and stong.

    Because I am growing some as cordons and a couple as pyramid shape I do a late summer prune. I will cut off top when weather warms up in early spring from plum

  • Caz WCaz W Posts: 1,353

    Like Alina, I generally leave mine alone and it has always done well - hope yours will too image

Sign In or Register to comment.