Forum home Fruit & veg

veg garden planning software

has any one ever used any of these software packages. if so which and what feature did you like dislike and what weakness did software have



  • Gary HobsonGary Hobson Posts: 1,892

    A long time ago I did try a garden design package. It was completely useless in every respect. I don't know if anything has changed since then. I doubt it.

    Firstly, anything that runs on a laptop or home computer will have nothing like the power and sophistication of professional packages used to design Olympic Park and similar.

    Then there is the problem of data entry. If you have a very small garden, do you really need a computer to keep track of things? If you have a large garden, and might conceivably require a computer, then the task of entering the co-ordinates and details of every single plant in your garden will be formidable.

    The way the package that I had represented plants was very poor. It was systematic. Vague coloured blobs were all it offered. You could not for example, supply a real photo of each plant, and let the package use that to build its image.

    The way the package represented such things as ponds, or pergolas was very primitive, and systematic. My pond and pergola simply did not have the same shape or appearance as the standard one they wanted to give me.

    There are several of these programs available from Amazon, and you can see what customers thought of them....

    Amazon also offer one called "Geoff Hamilton's 3 D Garden Designer". Geoff Hamilton was a respected presenter of Gardeners World. There are no reviews for that one. The price is £2 plus postage, or 1 penny second hand, also through Amazon. I haven't seen it. It might be worth a try. But don't expect too much.

  • gary i said veg garden planning software not general garden planning software the two are not same do read the topics first befotre posting otherwise it makes you look stupid.


  • joslowjoslow Posts: 218

    Why would anyone want to buy software to plan their veg when an A4 sheet of paper would do.

    Your rudeness to the only person who has replied will stop others from replying to your original question.

  • ObelixxObelixx Vendée, Western FrancePosts: 22,855

    If Plainleaf is who I think he is, he is known for being rude and also for posting threads and comments designed to create trouble.   He's been banned from umpteen gardening websites.  Best ignored.

    If anyone does want a veg garden planner for UK gardening, they could do worse than consult Tee Gee's Almanac.  He's an old poster on the Beeb and also A4A and keeps careful records of when to sow, plant out and harvest his fruit an veg.

    "We don't stop playing because we grow old; we grow old because we stop playing." - George Bernard Shaw
  • Gary HobsonGary Hobson Posts: 1,892

    Actually I admit to being totally ignorant about the orignal question, as I don't grow any vegetables. image

  • Miss BecksMiss Becks Posts: 3,468

    imageimageimage  Gary.

  • obelixx guess you still can't stay on topic or answer basic questions.

  • ObelixxObelixx Vendée, Western FrancePosts: 22,855

    I rest my case.  Plainleaf is Grid the Gardener amongst many other ids.

    "We don't stop playing because we grow old; we grow old because we stop playing." - George Bernard Shaw
  • marshmellomarshmello Posts: 683


  • Miss BecksMiss Becks Posts: 3,468

    Well whoever it is, they have proved themselves to be very rude, calling someone stupid for offering advice. Especially as already mentioned, a piece of paper, a pencil and research would be quite suffice. Which you could then scan to your PC for future reference. Or enter into a simple spreadsheet, which you could alter when needed.

    Maybe you should use your computer for other resources, plainleaf, like maybe googling the words 'Pot,' 'Kettle' and 'Black'.

    And to answer your original question. No.

Sign In or Register to comment.