Forum home Fruit & veg

Garlic

These were planted late last year and initially kept outside.  Moved into a heated greenhouse just before Xmas.  I've trimmed the dead leaves off them but they don't seem to be doing anything.  I've not grow these before so I just wondered if it was just a question of waiting:



At about 750 feet on the western edge of The Pennines.  Clay soil.  
«134

Posts

  • SueAtooSueAtoo Posts: 347
    Garlic is hardy and I believe needs the cold spell. Mine was planted outside, uncovered in about November and looks sturdier than these.
    East Dorset, new (to me) rather neglected garden.
  • I should also mention that I got the garlic from Lidl and didn't buy plants as recommended!
    At about 750 feet on the western edge of The Pennines.  Clay soil.  
  • ObelixxObelixx Posts: 29,839
    Buying culinary garlic from LIDL means you don't know what varietyy you have and whether or not it is suitable for your local conditions - climates, soil, aspect.  Nor is it guaranteed to be virus free.

    I think you need to be patient and give yours time to grow and, maybe, put it outside in a sunny spot where the extra light should help.  They are planted very close so don't expect fat bulbs.

    For various reasons I didn't get my garlic planted in December or January as I usually do and it has only recently gone in the ground with a trowel length between cloves and about 40cms between rows.   When I ran out of space I planted the leftover cloves in a window box in the polytunnel. 

    The ones in the ground are still hiding as it has turned cold and wet but the ones in the warmth are already 4cm high and looking sturdy.  I'll be using them as a cut and come again leaf crop rather than expecting bulbs to form.
    Vendée - 20kms from Atlantic coast.
    "We don't stop playing because we grow old; we grow old because we stop playing." - George Bernard Shaw
  • Hi Obelixx & SueAtoo

    Thank you for your comments. 

    It was a last minute decision to plant the 'Lidl' garlic, and I appreciate that this might not have been the best thing to do.

    I'm never sure about veg. being inside or outside.  Winters here (edge of Pennines) can be extremely cold and we seem to get some cold northerly winds at times.  I do check about planting the various veg. but the people who write about these things are assuming a more temperate climate so it's difficult for me.  I've only been growing veg. since I retired a couple of years ago and don't have much experience of this. 

    None of my neigbours attempt to grow vegetables in winter which should tell me something :)

    I think that the garlic isn't going to do too much but I'll bear with it for a few more weeks.  I though the same about some leeks a few weeks ago but they seem to be coming round.

    This makes me appreciate how good a gardener my father was.
    At about 750 feet on the western edge of The Pennines.  Clay soil.  
  • ObelixxObelixx Posts: 29,839
    @ Inthemoorlands    Before we moved here I gardened in Belgium for 25 years and had little success with garlic - too cold and wet too - but leeks are made of sterner stuff so yours may well pick up and do well.   Last year it didn't do well here because of early and prolonged heatwaves and drought.  Can't win sometimes.

    As for your garlic, it may be possibe to plant it out in a bed or space it in bigger pots but it usually needs a period of cold to encourage the cloves to form so put yours outside and see if that helps.  If not, just keep it in, or handy for, the kitchen and use it as a cut and come again crop.  Just don't cut too low down as it needs some green to keep it growing.
    Vendée - 20kms from Atlantic coast.
    "We don't stop playing because we grow old; we grow old because we stop playing." - George Bernard Shaw
  • Growing garlic is falling off a log easy, you need two things:
    1. To be able to read.
    2. Be able to follow simple instructions.

    Here is a guide on how to do it: https://www.rhs.org.uk/vegetables/garlic/grow-your-own
  • raisingirlraisingirl Posts: 7,006
    Growing garlic is falling off a log easy, you need two things:

    The OP is clearly able to grow garlic - it's there growing. Growing decent stuff is much more difficult.

    The stuff you bought is very likely Spanish, so feeling the cold at the moment. Give it time. Even if it was 'proper' cold climate suitable stuff, it wouldn't be ready until June at the earliest. It needs cold to start, heat later to develop flavour, just the right amount of water - it can be quite touchy. I get huge variations in the quality of the harvest, depending on the weather.

    I'd agree with others who said to plant it out if you have somewhere that doesn't get waterlogged to put it. I'm a lot further south but high up, so it does get (and stay) cold here and it is very wet. I think the garlic is OK with the cold but not keen on the wet. Even so, it is actually relatively hungry, so in your pot they may be too close together to develop well. 

    I'm going to plant 'spring' planting garlic this weekend. If you've got somewhere to do it, I'd suggest you try to plant those out in the next 2 or 3 weeks.
    “It's still magic even if you know how it's done.” 
  • Growing garlic is falling off a log easy, you need two things:
    1. To be able to read.
    2. Be able to follow simple instructions.

    if only it was that simple. 

    I'd bet that no one has watched more YouTube videos and read about growing vegetables than me. 

    I'd liken it to learning to drive a car or flying a plane by reading about how to do it.  There is no substitute for having a go.

    Last summer's vegetable harvest was a lot better than the previous summer (my first), so hopefully this summer will be even better.  I'm learning all the time.

    I'm going to plant 'spring' planting garlic this weekend. If you've got somewhere to do it, I'd suggest you try to plant those out in the next 2 or 3 weeks.
    I was wondering about binning the garlic that I have, getting some plants and starting again.  Can't make my mind up at the moment.

    It's been suggested that I have planted too many in the pots so i wonder how many should I have planted in pots of that size?  Most of our garden has been landscaped and consists of a wildlife/woodland garden with three water features.  My vegetable garden consists of a paved area by the greenhouse with a compost heap in the corner so everything must go into tubs ot troughs




    At about 750 feet on the western edge of The Pennines.  Clay soil.  
  • Growing garlic is falling off a log easy, you need two things:
    1. To be able to read.
    2. Be able to follow simple instructions.

    if only it was that simple. 

    I'd bet that no one has watched more YouTube videos and read about growing vegetables than me. 

    I'd liken it to learning to drive a car or flying a plane by reading about how to do it.  There is no substitute for having a go.

    Last summer's vegetable harvest was a lot better than the previous summer (my first), so hopefully this summer will be even better.  I'm learning all the time.

    I'm going to plant 'spring' planting garlic this weekend. If you've got somewhere to do it, I'd suggest you try to plant those out in the next 2 or 3 weeks.
    I was wondering about binning the garlic that I have, getting some plants and starting again.  Can't make my mind up at the moment.

    It's been suggested that I have planted too many in the pots so i wonder how many should I have planted in pots of that size?  Most of our garden has been landscaped and consists of a wildlife/woodland garden with three water features.  My vegetable garden consists of a paved area by the greenhouse with a compost heap in the corner so everything must go into tubs ot troughs





    It's falling off a log easy, you need two things:

    The OP is clearly able to grow garlic
    They clearly aren't otherwise they wouldn't be asking here.

    InTheMoorlands 
    It is that simple, I don't know where you read to plant Supermarket garlic, nor put them in a heated greenhouse. Both the guide I showed you and this: 
    https://www.gardenersworld.com/how-to/grow-plants/how-to-grow-garlic/

    State specifically not to use it.

    Read the guides, plant some Spring garlic and try an over Winter type in November by following what they say do.

    And yes, you should have one clove per pot, then you can grow it on in there.

    It isn't really like learning to fly or drive. If you don't take any notice of advice when you do that you'll kill yourself and/or other people.
    It's unlikely you'll achieve that growing garlic, but you never know!  :p
  • EustaceEustace Posts: 2,112
    @InTheMoorlands I would move the pot outdoors; whatever you have planted, let it be. I've grown supermarket ones in a builder's bucket. Though they may not be the best harvest, still good as 1 or 2 bulbs had multiplied to 10+. The flavour was good too.
    Oxford. The City of Dreaming Spires.
    And then my heart with pleasure fills,
    And dances with the daffodils (roses). Taking a bit of liberty with Wordsworth :)

Sign In or Register to comment.