Splits in Pleached red robins

IronSquirrel

So the red robins I had previously diagnosed with ‘having trouble getting used to being planted, pleached and in slightly clayish soil underneath the compost Have these as well, 

I’m worried that there’s risk that ice can split it, or that it’s a sign they’re not grown right. I’ll find the pic of them in their glory in a few min

IronSquirrel

IronSquirrel

IronSquirrel

Dovefromabove

I'd not be at all happy with that staking ... they're strapped far too tightly and the stakes are too close to the trunks ... there should be a gap to allow for growth and a little movement.  Can't really see what's happening with the splits because of the staking. 

Dovefromabove

On a closer look ... in the second picture it looks as if the tree trunk is actually swelling around the stake.
No wonder the trunk is deforming and splitting.

Is that black hosepipe it has wrapped around it? 🤯

This gives some idea of how to stake pleached trees using proper tree ties and spacers

https://instahedge.com/support/hedge-care/tree-staking/

JennyJ

I agree, it looks as if the tight ties have damaged the bark.

Uff

I agree with both, it's quite clear where the ties have done the damage. 

IronSquirrel

I’ll ask if they’ve been told if the stakes are a short term measure. Also not sure if it’s in those photos , but the one and only actual store bought tree strap … is the one thing that just hangs lose around a stake not being used AS a tree strap

JennyJ

I think pleached trees might need to be tied in to a permanent framework.

A properly-fitted tree tie should look something like the pic in this page  https://www.ashridgetrees.co.uk/buckle-and-strap-ties , not too tight around the trunk, with a "stopper" between the trunk and the stake so they don't touch each other, with a buckle or fastening that can be loosened gradually as the tree grows, and with the fastening against the stake not the tree trunk.

IronSquirrel

Hi, I didn't know whether I should start a new thread but this one attracted enough knowledgable people so I thought I'd keep it 

So my friends gardeners and bak-up gardeners have in one way or another fallen through, and worst of all haven't even suggested anything.

Given the incoming winter risks, cracking, damp etc, I'm wondering if the two following steps should be taken,

and I'd like opinions on both, because the first is the one most likely to damage their treasured trees if handled incorrectly, and the second I've simply no clue toward its effectiveness.


1. Remove the backing stakes, replace in a manner depicted 


2. use something called 'tree wrap', which likes like selotape made out of brown wrapping paper, and wrap the trees from below the base to the first branches and just have them removed come spring.

thanks!