I suppose I meant the ones sold by specialist companies that cost £150 to £200. I assume people buy them to provide instant impact but I wondered how easily they would transfer (as a general rule) and would also be concerned about how they would stand up to wind.
If you search 'Tony Kirkham air pots' on YouTube you will see he views them positively when it comes to tree growth and root development. Tpny is head of the arboretum, Kew.
With air pots, the roots do not spiral within the pot system, meaning that when placed in the ground the roots travel outwards in all directions. Majestic Trees major on the fact their trees are all in air pots.
That said, I have bought good-sized trees from suppliers (Barcham Trees) who do not use the air pot system and have had success with them, even in windy locations. This is my Prunus avium 'Plena' from Barcham, bought as a tree with a 10-12cm girth. It's been in the ground a little over 10 years.
If you're talking about the kind of trees that they use in Chelsea show gardens for instant impact, my personal opinion is that you'd have a lot of worry for a lot of money. However, as Rachel says, the air pot system is very effective, and Barcham are a very good nursery (good enough for The Queen) https://www.barcham.co.uk/ I would go for a mid size tree which would be easier to look after, but that's just me.
Thanks for the excellent replies. If AnniD has time to post again at some point could you give me an idea of what you would class as mid size. Many thanks again.
There are many tree nurseries if you search online, if you can find one local to you so much the better. If you can pay them a visit l'd strongly advise you to do so, failing that give them a call. Local nursery knowledge, where they know the area, the local conditions etc. is best. If you don't have anywhere local, again l suggest ringing (or email). Nothing beats the personal touch .
Posts
I assume people buy them to provide instant impact but I wondered how easily they would transfer (as a general rule) and would also be concerned about how they would stand up to wind.
I would imagine that the company which provides them will also plant them and ensure that they are adequately staked.
If you live in Derbyshire, as I do.
With air pots, the roots do not spiral within the pot system, meaning that when placed in the ground the roots travel outwards in all directions. Majestic Trees major on the fact their trees are all in air pots.
That said, I have bought good-sized trees from suppliers (Barcham Trees) who do not use the air pot system and have had success with them, even in windy locations. This is my Prunus avium 'Plena' from Barcham, bought as a tree with a 10-12cm girth. It's been in the ground a little over 10 years.
However, as Rachel says, the air pot system is very effective, and Barcham are a very good nursery (good enough for The Queen)
https://www.barcham.co.uk/
I would go for a mid size tree which would be easier to look after, but that's just me.
https://www.chewvalleytrees.co.uk/products/category/trees?size=medium-10-15-metres&shape=any&evergreen=any&native=any&leaf-colour=any&flower-colour=any&autumn-colour=any&fruit-colour=any&season=any&uses=use-screening&hedging=any&growth-rate=any&pollination-group=any&pollination-type=any&fruiting-period=any&fruit-attributes=any&fruit-storage=any&fruit-colour=any&fruit-size=any&type=any&orderby=latin&sort=asc&results=30
There are many tree nurseries if you search online, if you can find one local to you so much the better. If you can pay them a visit l'd strongly advise you to do so, failing that give them a call. Local nursery knowledge, where they know the area, the local conditions etc. is best.
If you don't have anywhere local, again l suggest ringing (or email). Nothing beats the personal touch
I love this forum.